The American Hotel

The American Hotel is a hotel Sag Harbor located in United States.

8 / 10
106
ratings
  • Phone

    (631) 725-3535

  • Website

    theamericanhotel.com

  • Facebook

    401689559873049

  • Type

    Hotel

Address

45 Main St Sag Harbor , NY 11963 United States

Comments / 33


Keywords:

backgammon table outdoor seating roasted chicken desserts bar healthy food coffee brunch food meats lunch banana fosters dinner friendly staff bison almonds
Linda Song

It's no Maryland crab cake and the 'burger ' in the title is misleading, but their crab cake burger (rather, sandwich ) is really good!

Joel

This is a wonderful restaurant where the food is always good without pretense , smoked salmon platter oysters and the crab cakes , and for desert banana foster

Linda Song

You don't expect it, but their coffee is absolutely delicious. I had to stop myself from pouring more! Hahaha would have been up all night!

Linda Song

Let's talk banana fosters . Wow. It looks heavy, but it's not a stomach killer at all. Just delicious caramelly goodness.

David Taylor

Lovely terrace to go with lovely food! Watch the cars and people as you enjoy a sandwich and a glass of rose .

The Corcoran Group

Sit at the bar with Vinnie or Paul, grab a backgammon table in the front room, dine outside and watch the crowds, or host an intimate party in one of the private rooms.

Travel + Leisure

This red-brick Victorian hasn’t changed much since 1846. And that’s just how guests like it, with its faded elegance, backgammon tables in the lobby, and a bartender who will soon know your name.

Joel

Classic old style Americana , French cuisine from 20 years ago but really good and really nice wine list .

Stephen B

Andres (and Dennis) are great waiters ! Their service and the food made for a great night. Make sure to try the crab cakes

Robert S

Best wine list , late night bar , for a more mature crowd. Fun brunch on patio .

Rainbow LA

Ask for Richard the Prince of Leonard street during the day. Have a Davidoff 6000 while playing Backgammon with the Wasps, take a gander at cougars and gays.

Sam Pezzullo

An iconic spot in the Hamptons. Have a drink at the bar and play some backgammon. Say hi to Billy Joel for me.

Gaëlle Ma Tata

Very tasty lobster sandwich in a nice and luxus atmosphere

Ellen Antonucci

Great almonds at the bar . Roast chicken and the duck are highly recommended.

Matz Eklund

Friendly staff and very nice oysters

Vanity Fair

This storied bar has hosted book editor Robert Loomis, who prefers a hardy Jack Daniel’s on the rocks.

Pia Fouilloux

The macadamia tart it's like a little bit of heaven! ????

Daniel Powell

More traditional, food was great but people come for the wine list

Ernie Huber

Very cool but expensive . It's like you stepped back in time.

Alonso Carral

the scallop risotto is amazing

allie white

This place reeks of wealth. Super iconic, classy and old fashioned. Billy Joel is standing next to me.

Lisette P

Possibly the best Croque Madame I've ever had.

Zina Malcolm

The salmon with chanterelle mushrooms was orgasmic! The service was amazing!

Savannah Petrick

grab a drink before dinner

Fernando Mihanovich

Great bar , excellent bullshot

Cecil Broderick

Great Bar , awesome Bison Capacio

James Rivera

Great brunch & bloody Mary's

Patricia Goodrich

????Awesome!

Patrick Mclaughlin

Take you grandparents!

Steve Haweeli

Get the lobster BLT for lunch !

Crystal Gardner

Some times people become mayor when they don't deserve to

Ann Hdz

Too nice and pretty

Crystal Gardner

Some people check in when they aren't even there yet

Similar places nearby :

8.8
Hotel
Baron's Cove

Sunsets on the patio with live music tops off any weekend. Excellent food and terrific views of the marina. - Susan Fellner

Hotel
Sag Harbor Inn

Clean & newly Renovated. Waterfront rooms w views of marina & sunset - Robert S

7.1
Restaurant
Lulu Kitchen & Bar

I’ve had the baked cauliflower, pizzas and their burgers. All are awesome! The staff are great!! - Howard Herman

7.8
Dive Bar
Murf's Backstreet Tavern

Great local dive bar. A must in Sag Harbor. - Daniel McDonough

7.7
Burgers
LT Burger in the Harbor

Tuna burger is fantastic! Great service & delicious food. Soft drinks for kids doesn't include apple juice. They'll charge you for it. - Eric Black

7.9
Yogurt
BuddhaBerry Frozen Yogurt Café

Awesome frozen yogurt, tons of toppings, and like the Hamptons, a few more bucks than normal. - The Corcoran Group