Secret Sandwich Society

Secret Sandwich Society is a sandwich spot Fayetteville located in United States.

9 / 10
128
ratings
  • Phone

    (304) 574-4777

  • Website

    secretsandwichsociety.com

  • Facebook

    107704959264891

  • Type

    Sandwich Spot

Address

103 Keller Ave Fayetteville , WV 25840 United States

Outdoor Seating Yes
Menus Brunch, Lunch, Dinner
Drinks Beer, Full Bar

Comments / 42


Keywords:

sandwiches hoover loaded fries mckinley good for dates french fries trendy great value good for a quick meal good for groups casual homemade ketchup chocolate cheesecake beer coffee restaurants soup turkey music meats
Mike Shade

Great sandwiches . Service was a little slow but definitely worth the wait. Is the kind of place that should be on Diners, Drive-ins and Dives

Paige Blaylock

Love their loaded fries & homemade ketchup ! The only downside to this place is its limited capacity. They should add on to their deck/expand seating. Consistent with awesome food & delicious coffee !

Kathleen M

The Adams is delicious! A roast pork sandwich with pimento cheese , pickles , and jalapeño ! Perfect flavor combination

Brian Zickafoose

Our appetizer - cheese fries - was a mound of fries covered in pimento cheese . The Rawhide Burger is a spicy delicacy featuring jalapeños , fried egg over-easy and aioli sauce . It will make you sweat.

PureWow

Show off your patriotism by ordering the Fillmore or Lincoln. All of the sandwiches are named after U.S. presidents at this speakeasy-type joint. Read more

Chris Vuocolo

Nice curation on the beer last. Good choices across styles and a good mix of local and national brands.

Brian Zickafoose

The Moroccan chicken stew over a bowl of couscous was like booyah for my belly!! Nom nom nom and topped off with a tasty pitcher of porter !

h

Check out the live music upstairs! Quirky setting with improv electric ukelele and mandolin from local climbers!

Travel Green Appalachia

Meat comes from a local farm and is roasted on site. Cutlery is biodegradable. Local draft beer . Good vegetarian sandwiches . Very unique sandwiches

Bob ????☎????Ⓜ♒ M

Food and service are always the best. Weekends are packed try week days.

Steve Poland

Great food- sandwiches , salads and soup . Great beer selection . Shhhh

Tashia Hippler

Breakfast & Lunch menu available ALL DAY! get your lunch to go when you're getting your bfast , and your entire order is 10% off! Bring your own coffee cup for .25 off your coffee - see you soon! Read more

Josh Baker

There is more that isn't on the menu. Everything is excellent. Dont nitpick over specific ingredients because they're probably nothing like you've had, before.

Brenda Dane

Awesome pimento fries !!!

Caleb Parsons

My wife and I heard a lot of hype around this one. Our sandwiches were very dry and lacking in flavor, but the chips and fries are pretty good. Overall a decent lunch , but I can't say I'd go back.

Josh Baker

The Washington sounds odd, but is the best apple on a hot sandwich you'll ever have.

Brad Zickafoose

If you like turkey , muenster , and onions you can't go wrong with the Rockefeller breakfast sandwich . It's mighty tasty.

T W

The Eisenhower with loaded fries and the Dolly salad !

Amber

Everything is amazing! My favorite is the Lafayette :)

Jesse Vickers

Great food with great people. Try the McKinley if you like meatloaf .

Caitlin Clements

Southern Living raves about their gourmet sandwiches

Justin Suissa

Tasty and creative sandwiches

Justin Suissa

Tasty and creative sandwiche

Visit Southern West Virginia

Try the Ulysses. Peach jam is delicious. You can also order the fabulous breakfast sandwiches all day!

Cutter Houck

Simple comforting experience. Its nice to have a great sandwich cut with a hoppy beer .

Christian Parsons

Amazing chocolate cheesecake , definitely a keeper.

Misty Pauley

My all time favorite place to eat!!

Murray Manoli

Great food but service was sloooow...

ben curnett

Good beer list , English-style pint glasses , and a pic of George Washington on the wall. Perfect.

Brittany Johnson

Food is amazing.

Katrina Bowers

The Hoover on a brioche bun !

Drew Johnston

The McKinley Sandwich .

Harold Summers

Polk is delicious

Thomas

Soup of the day.

C T

get it all

Opossum Creek Retreat Cabins

Working my way thru menu one at a time not cheap for a reason really good meats

Jared Varner

Awesome food!!

C T

Long wait great food

Sandy Call

With my GNO girls!!

Katie Butler

Get the Hoover sandwich !

Kurt Erler

Get the McKinley . Bacon Jam !!!

h

Servers dont take food allergies seriously. Learned this the hard way when getting nuts and milk in my salad - after mentioning milk and nut allergies... Felt so sick. Never again.

Similar places nearby :

6.7
Fast Food
Arby's

Best kept cleanest and most polite manager I've ever dealt with at an Arby's. 2 thumbs up - Clinton Logan

6.0
Fast Food
Wendy's

Horrible in store service. Completely ignored for five minutes before we were acknowledged. Annoying. - Kaila Copenhaver

7.7
American
Cathedral Cafe

Wraps & pot roast melts were great! Awesome fresh coffee! Friendly & attentive wait staff. A - Travis King

9.4
Scenic Lookout
New River Gorge Overlook

Great view from the Overlook! The fudge shop near by is AMAZING! - Kelsie Kessick