Pies and Pints Pizzeria

Our Fayetteville location will be undergoing renovations until March 4thish. We'll see you in Fayetteville in a few weeks with a new and improved kitchen to serve you better!

9 / 10
176
ratings
Address

219 W Maple Ave Fayetteville , WV 25840 United States

Reservations No
Credit Cards Yes
Outdoor Seating Yes
Menus Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, Happy Hour
Drinks Beer, Cocktails

Comments / 74


Keywords:

pizza bridge brew works thai pie beer root beer spinach salad gluten-free food good for dates sandwiches good for groups casual buffet great value desserts brownies grapes Gouda cheese coconut ham garlic
Brian Sammons

I especially like the antipasta salad , the Cuban Pork Pie , the Hot Ham and Pepper pie, the Grape pie and of course the desserts are all delicious. Try the Bridge Brew Works beers !

Brian Zickafoose

Just when I thought I could no longer be impressed by a slice of pizza , P & P delivers their finest dish yet with the Sri-Racha Shrimp Pie. Spicy with a stunningly clean finish. Refreshing and tasty.

Mark Adams

WOW. Delicious food. Must stop if you are at the New River Gorge National park . Best Pizza and Beers anywhere east of the Mississippi. Desserts are not to be missed. Would recommend to everyone!!!

Ally

So delicious. The tomato sauce for the pizza is seriously amaze-balls. Pine and swine pizza was to die for. Love this place. Service is also excellent. Had dinner here one night & came back for lunch !

Brian Zickafoose

The chicken gouda pie is amazingly delectable. It tastefully blends chunk chicken , melted gouda cheese and red onion and chive slivers over white sauce and a perfectly fired crust. Bring an appetite.

Megan Irvine

One of the best pizzas I’ve had. Perfect crust, and lots of topping choices. Also good beer selection . Service was excellent.

Megan Hodges

Awesome pizza , and I'm a New Yorker... Really creAtive pies. Loved the Thai - great coconut flavor . Also loved the grape , but strong on the rosemary flavor so only if that's your thing.

Marie La Rue

Local dining hotspot, gets super busy. Creative pizza selection, with gluten free and vegan options available.

Radhapriya McCabe

The black bean pizza is AMAZING. A delightful treat for vegheads & carnivorous ones alike.

Candice Holliday

Everything! Grape pie is my favorite my boyfriends is the pulled pork pie . Roasted garlic app with goat cheese is phenomenal!

Kimmery Stepanek

Jenny is the best waitress !!! 1/2 Gouda chx and 1/2 caprese pie and a pitcher of keg draft root beer . Happy tummy!!!

cris

Everything is great. Of the appetizers , get the chicken wings and garlic bread with cheese .

Travel Green Appalachia

Great handcrafted pizza and usually the first local place to get Bridge Brew Works seasonal brews .

porter ny

Terrific pies, chicken gouda and craft beers and unbeatable, best I've ever tasted.

Hope Fahey

Had a pizza hand made with eggplant , red peppers and black beans . ...plus a local brew . OMG..outstanding!

Bridge Brew Works

Try anything on the menu. Seriously. You cannot go wrong. Several of our beers on tap along with a wide variety of other quality beers .

Matt

The Pistachio Pesto Pizza is great!

Alli Pennington

The tree to the right of the play set looks like an elephant!! The mozzarella caprese was AMAZING!!!

Charles Lord

Absolutely everything, ask for the balsamic chicken pie . It is no longer on the menu but it's my fav

Bradley Carter

Get the wings and a local brew from Bridge Brew Works . Thai Pie was good, but not earth-shattering.

porter ny

Best pizza ever. And we are from my. Chicken gouda ans pine and swine.

Margaret Massey

The Cuban and the grape pizza were both great!

Angie Purcell

Fantastic pizza in a great atmosphere. Try the spinach garlic pie!

Kaysie Fry

Best wings I have ever had. The pizza skin pizza is great.

Derek Schweigel

Steak and cheese sandwich and nachos are amazing

Russ Ripp

Margherita pizza is excellent, salads are huge.

Lee Morelock

Local beers are great, pizza is even better!

Rhonda Coleman

Delicious!! Spinach Salad is a real winner, Cuban Pulled Pork Pizza is THE BOMB!!

Cutter Houck

Bridge Brew Pale is nice. Cant get enough of the steak and crimini pie. Can you really go wrong?

Tim Snyder

The wings are fantastic!

Holly Foley

Everything. Love the Flatbread

Alyssa Anderson

Margarita pizza is the best hands down!

Bob Sim

Great food and better beer selection

Daniel Rubin

Cuban pork , best pizza in the world. Bridgebrew works Oktoberfest also great

Laura Talarowski

Get the grape pizza with Gorgonzola .

Madison Jordan

The Mediterranean pizza is one of the best I have EVER had. Ask for William.

Paul Hansen

Pizza is amazing

Paul Ray

Classic is perfect

Nathan Swartz

Beers for dad, playground out back for the kiddos.

Visit Southern West Virginia

Added wings to their menu - and wow! You have to try them

Grant Mizell

Grape is the best!

Grant Mizell

Can't make up your mind? Order 1/2 and 1/2.

Nell Lilly

Black bean pizza and everything.

Visit Southern West Virginia

Never had a bad pie here. Love the pork nachos and the peanut butter brownie is so good it's sinful.

Lee Kennedy

Quench your thirst after a day of climbing with one of the local drafts .

Reid Williams

Reid Recommends: Cuban Pork Pie (or sandwich ), spinach salad , and a pitcher of Sierra Nevada. Scrumptious!

T White

Even the cheesecake is phenom! Get both the raspberry and the chocolate sauce for uber delight!

Rob

Try the Grape pie and the Gouda

pat strader

Try one of the great beers (Rogue!) and pair it with one of their unique pies. Read more

John Paterakis

Pizza Skins !

Similar places nearby :

Pizza
Gino's Pizza & Spaghetti

Great wings! - Sean Moses

6.7
Fast Food
Arby's

Best kept cleanest and most polite manager I've ever dealt with at an Arby's. 2 thumbs up - Clinton Logan

5.3
Fast Food
McDonald's

Slow service in drive thru. 20 minutes wait on fast food. Non-caring manager at door taking smoke break with another employee. See pic. - Rusty Adkins

9.4
Scenic Lookout
New River Gorge Overlook

Great view from the Overlook! The fudge shop near by is AMAZING! - Kelsie Kessick

5.7
Big Box Store
Walmart Supercenter

Huge selection, no lines. - Sarah

8.5
Other Outdoors
Adventures On The Gorge

Great set up! Came here in the Fall and it is beautiful. Cabins are very nice! So much to do here! - jiresell